Best Practices & Guidelines

Your complete guide to using strict-path correctly and ergonomically.

This page provides the essential decision matrices, core principles, and quick references for daily use. For deeper dives, we've split detailed content into focused chapters—each covering a single topic so you can digest one concept at a time.

📚 Focused Chapters (Deep Dives)

For detailed explanations and comprehensive examples, see these focused chapters:

• Why Naive Approaches Fail → - The 5 broken approaches and why path security is hard
• Real-World Patterns → - Production-ready examples you can copy-paste (LLM agents, archives, web servers, config, multi-tenant)
• Common Operations → - Complete reference for joins, parents, renames, deletion, metadata, copy operations
• Policy & Reuse → - When to use VirtualRoot/PathBoundary types vs sugar constructors (performance, testing, serde)
• Authorization Architecture → - Compile-time authorization with marker types (basic auth, permissions, dynamic elevation)

Start here for fundamentals, then jump to focused chapters when you need details.

Why strict-path Exists (TL;DR)

Path security isn't one problem—it's a class of interacting problems. Every "simple" approach (check for ../, canonicalize then check, normalize, allowlist chars, combine checks) creates new attack surface:

• Encoding bypasses (URL encoding, double encoding, Unicode normalization)
• Race conditions (TOCTOU with symlinks: CVE-2022-21658)
• Platform gaps (Windows 8.3 names, UNC paths, ADS: CVE-2019-9855, CVE-2017-17793)
• Performance costs (repeated filesystem calls)
• Future CVEs (new attack vectors require updating every check)

strict-path solved this problem class once, correctly, so you don't have to.

→ Full analysis with CVE examples →

Pick The Right Type (Quick Reference)

30-Second Decision Guide

External/untrusted segments (HTTP, DB, manifests, LLM output, archive entries):

• Detection (90% of cases): StrictPath::with_boundary(..).strict_join(..) — detects escapes, rejects attacks
• Containment (10% of cases): VirtualPath::with_root(..).virtual_join(..) — silently clamps escapes, isolates users

Internal/trusted paths (hardcoded, CLI, env): Use Path/PathBuf; only validate when combining with untrusted segments.

For policy reuse across many joins: Keep a PathBoundary or VirtualRoot and call strict_join(..)/virtual_join(..) repeatedly.

Decision Matrix by Source

Security Philosophy: Detect vs. Contain

The fundamental distinction: Are path escapes attacks or expected behavior?

StrictPath — Detect & Reject (Default, 90%)

• Philosophy: "If it tries to escape, I want to know"
• Returns: Err(PathEscapesBoundary) on escape attempts
• Use for: Archives, file uploads, config loading, security boundaries
• Always available (no feature flag)

VirtualPath — Contain & Redirect (Opt-in, 10%)

• Philosophy: "Let it try to escape, but silently contain it"
• Behavior: Silently clamps escapes within boundary
• Use for: Multi-tenant systems, malware sandboxes, security research, user isolation
• Requires: virtual-path feature in Cargo.toml

How They Differ

Attempting ../../../etc/passwd:

• StrictPath: Err(PathEscapesBoundary) → log, alert, reject
• VirtualPath: Silently clamped to boundary → contained, not reported

Symlink to /etc/passwd:

• StrictPath: Follows, validates target → Error if outside boundary
• VirtualPath: Treats as relative → clamped to vroot/etc/passwd

Critical Rule: Use StrictPath for archives to detect attacks. VirtualPath hides them.

Golden Rule: If you didn't create the path yourself, secure it first.

→ Full comparison with examples →

When to Use Policy Types vs. Sugar

Sugar constructors (StrictPath::with_boundary(..), VirtualPath::with_root(..)) are great for simple, one-off operations.

Policy types (PathBoundary, VirtualRoot) matter when you need:

• Policy reuse (canonicalize once, join many times)
• Performance (1 canonicalization vs 1000 in loops)
• Testability (inject test boundaries)
• Serde integration (contextual deserialization)
• Clear signatures (encode guarantees in types)

Quick Example:

#![allow(unused)]
fn main() {
use strict_path::PathBoundary;

// ❌ SLOW: 1000 canonicalizations
for name in files {
    let boundary = PathBoundary::try_new(base)?;
    boundary.strict_join(name)?;
}

// ✅ FAST: 1 canonicalization
let boundary = PathBoundary::try_new(base)?;
for name in files {
    boundary.strict_join(name)?; // Reuses canonical state
}
}

Rule of thumb: Start with sugar; upgrade to policy types when you need reuse, performance, or testing.

→ Full guide with benchmarks, serde patterns, and testing examples →

Encode Guarantees In Function Signatures

Helpers that touch the filesystem must encode safety in their signatures:

Two canonical patterns:

1. Accept validated path when validation already happened: fn save(p: &StrictPath) -> io::Result<()>
2. Accept boundary + segment when validation happens inside: fn load(b: &PathBoundary, name: &str) -> io::Result<String>

Don't construct boundaries/roots inside helpers — boundary choice is policy; make it explicit at call sites.

→ Full patterns with examples →

Multi‑User Isolation (VirtualPath)

VirtualPath (opt-in via virtual-path feature) is for containment scenarios: multi-tenant systems, malware sandboxes, security research.

• Per-user: Create VirtualRoot per user, call virtual_join(..) for all operations
• Share helpers: Borrow strict view with vpath.as_unvirtual()
• Use for: Multi-tenant isolation, observing malicious behavior safely

NOT for: Archive extraction (use StrictPath to detect attacks, not hide them)

→ Full multi-tenant example →

Interop & Display

Interop (pass to AsRef<Path> APIs): path.interop_path() — no allocations

Display:

• System paths: strictpath_display() on PathBoundary/StrictPath
• User-facing: virtualpath_display() on VirtualPath

Never: interop_path().to_string_lossy() for display

Directory Discovery vs Validation

Discovery (walking): Use .read_dir(), collect names via entry.file_name()

Validation: Re-join discovered names through strict_join/virtual_join before I/O

#![allow(unused)]
fn main() {
for entry in boundary.read_dir()? {
    let name = entry?.file_name();
    let validated = boundary.strict_join(&name.to_string_lossy())?; // Validate!
    // Now safe to use validated path
}
}

Don't validate constants like "." — only validate untrusted segments.

Multi‑User Isolation (VirtualPath for Containment)

Note: VirtualPath is opt-in via the virtual-path feature. Use it when you need containment (multi-tenant isolation, sandboxes) rather than detection (security boundaries).

• Per‑user/tenant: for small flows, construct a root via VirtualPath::with_root(..) and join untrusted names with virtual_join(..). For larger flows and reuse, create a VirtualRoot per user and call virtual_join(..).
• Share strict helpers by borrowing the strict view: vpath.as_unvirtual().

#![allow(unused)]
fn main() {
fn upload(user_root: &VirtualRoot, filename: &str, bytes: &[u8]) -> std::io::Result<()> {
  let vpath = user_root.virtual_join(filename)?;
  vpath.create_parent_dir_all()?;
  vpath.write(bytes)
}

// Sugar-first call site (one-off):
// let vroot = VirtualPath::with_root(format!("./cloud/user_{user_id}"))?;
// let vpath = vroot.virtual_join(filename)?; // same guarantees; keep VirtualRoot for reuse
}

When to use each for archives:

• StrictPath for production archive extraction — detect malicious paths, reject compromised archives, alert users
• VirtualPath for sandbox/research — safely analyze suspicious archives by containing escapes while observing behavior
• StrictPath for file uploads to shared storage — reject attacks at the security boundary
• StrictPath for config loading — fail explicitly on untrusted paths that try to escape

The key: use StrictPath to detect attacks in production; use VirtualPath to contain behavior in research/analysis scenarios.

Interop & Display

• Interop (pass into AsRef<Path> APIs): path.interop_path() (no allocations).
• Display:
  • System‑facing: strictpath_display() on PathBoundary/StrictPath
  • User‑facing: virtualpath_display() on VirtualPath
• Never use interop_path().to_string_lossy() for display.

Directory Discovery vs Validation

• Discovery (walking): call boundary.read_dir() (or vroot.read_dir()), collect names via entry.file_name(), then re‑join with strict_join/virtual_join to validate before I/O.
• Validation: join those relatives via boundary.strict_join(..) or vroot.virtual_join(..) before I/O. For small flows without a reusable root, you can construct via StrictPath::with_boundary(..) or VirtualPath::with_root(..) and then join.
• Don’t validate constants like "."; only validate untrusted segments.

Common Operations (Quick Reference)

Always use dimension-specific methods (strict_* / virtualpath_*). Never use std::path methods on leaked paths.

Available operations:

• Joins: strict_join(..) / virtual_join(..) — validate and combine paths
• Parents: strictpath_parent() / virtualpath_parent() — navigate up directory tree
• Filenames: strictpath_with_file_name(..) / strictpath_with_extension(..) — modify names/extensions
• Rename: strict_rename(..) / virtual_rename(..) — move/rename within boundary
• Deletion: .remove_file(), .remove_dir(), .remove_dir_all() — safe deletion
• Metadata: .metadata(), .exists(), .is_file(), .is_dir() — inspect properties
• Copy: .copy(&dest) — duplicate files
• I/O: .read(), .read_to_string(), .write(), .create_file() — file operations

→ Complete operations guide with examples →

Naming Conventions

Variables reflect domain, not type:

• ✅ Good: config_dir, uploads_root, archive_src, tenant_vroot
• ❌ Bad: boundary, jail, source_ prefix, _path suffix

Keep names consistent with the directory they represent.

Do / Don’t

• Do: validate once at the boundary, pass types through helpers.
• Do: use VirtualRoot for per‑user isolation; borrow strict view for shared helpers.
• Do: prefer impl AsRef<Path> in helper params where you forward to validation.
• Don’t: wrap secure types in Path::new/PathBuf::from.
• Don’t: use interop_path().as_ref() or as_unvirtual().interop_path() (use interop_path() directly).
• Don’t: use lossy strings for display or comparisons.

Testing & Doctests

• Encode guarantees in function signatures
• Use *_create constructors for temp directories in tests
• Prefer offline simulations with deterministic inputs
• Clean up test directories after tests

Learn More

All detailed content has been moved to focused chapters for digestibility:

Core Concepts:

• Why Naive Approaches Fail → - 5 broken approaches with CVE examples
• Real-World Patterns → - Production-ready examples:
  • LLM Agent File Manager
  • Archive Extraction (detect vs contain patterns)
  • Web File Server with marker types
  • Configuration Manager
  • Multi-Tenant Cloud Storage

Practical Guides:

• Common Operations → - Complete reference for joins, parents, rename, delete, metadata, copy
• Policy & Reuse → - When to use VirtualRoot/PathBoundary vs sugar (performance, testing, serde)

Advanced Topics:

• Authorization Architecture → - Compile-time authorization with marker types

Quick Reference Card

Type Selection (30 seconds)

Sugar vs Policy Types

Core Operations

#![allow(unused)]
fn main() {
// Validate
let file = boundary.strict_join("path")?;

// I/O
file.write(b"data")?;
let content = file.read_to_string()?;

// Metadata
if file.exists() && file.metadata()?.len() > 0 { }

// Rename/Move
let renamed = file.strict_rename("newpath")?;

// Display
println!("System: {}", file.strictpath_display());
println!("User: {}", vpath.virtualpath_display()); // VirtualPath only
}

Do / Don't Checklist

✅ DO:

• Validate untrusted segments before I/O
• Pass &StrictPath / &VirtualPath to encode guarantees
• Use dimension-specific methods (strict_* / virtualpath_*)
• Call interop_path() only for AsRef<Path> APIs
• Name variables by domain (uploads_root, config_dir)

❌ DON'T:

• Wrap secure types in Path::new() / PathBuf::from()
• Use std::path methods on leaked paths
• Use interop_path() for display (use *_display())
• Construct boundaries inside helpers
• Validate constants like "." (only untrusted segments)

Anti-Patterns Reference

For detailed anti-patterns and fixes, see: Anti-Patterns Guide →

That's it! This page is your quick reference. Dive into the focused chapters when you need details.

For source-level API documentation: API Reference (strict-path crate docs) →